Mercedes CLA Forum banner

Mercedes Benz Maintanence Cost and Reliability

17101 Views 17 Replies 11 Participants Last post by  sleepyhead
It seems like there is a big assumption that german cars in general have very expensive maintenance costs and aren't very reliable.

Is there any data to prove or disprove this? How much is it really more to maintain a Mercedes Benz over say an Acura/Lexus/Infiniti?
1 - 18 of 18 Posts
From my understanding is that maintenance for any German or European vehicle is at least 15-20% more than your average cost of service. And this is not only at the dealerships.

Not sure where i read an article of comparable reliability for brands of vehicles, I think it was JD Powers, but since the 90s japanese vehicles have been at the top and known for reliability. The german auto makers always released new gadgets but were prone to failing. Not only did they create a hassle but werent necessary. It seems like the past times were having the newest technology and who was to bring it out first without testing. Mercedes vehicles can last long but who is not to say they've had a couple hiccups in between. Ask any real owner, it doesnt matter is it breaks by an inch or a mile, breaking is breaking. So off to the dealership you go with a frown.
Ask any real owner, it doesnt matter is it breaks by an inch or a mile, breaking is breaking. So off to the dealership you go with a frown.
hahaha. am I the only one who got that one? :D
The electric brakes on the older E Class were a good example of such a fiasco.
It is 2013 though. It seems like the newer cars are starting to become more reliable. At least in terms of electronics. I remember older BMWs, Mercedes, and Audi vehicles had many electrical problems down the road. Anyone who owns an older Mercedes Benz knows what I'm talking about.
My 2008 isn't all that brilliant either.
What sort of problems are you having with your 09 B?

I'm not saying that the problem is fixed but I do think it's getting better. The maintenance problem isn't as bad as it use to be. People blow it way out of proportion.

The truth is people are starting to have problems with Infiniti, Acura, Lexus (japanese luxury brands) more often now and the German brands are starting to become more reliable. Most of the Japanese luxury manufacturers shifted manufacturing over to USA and quality control has gone down alot. I've heard many complains about Infinitis have problems often from friends who have recently purchased them. I've also read of many problems with the Acura cars having bad quality control. In terms of the motors the japanese cars still have great reliability but the electronics aren't exactly as perfect as people say they are.
Well Mercedes does replace my 2003 E500 brake module for free @ 90k miles and give me a free loaner. In contrast a Honda dealer charge me $55 engine diagnose fee for the lifetime warranty seat belt replacement for Accord.
I think Consumer Reports and JD Power (BTW, it is not Powers) put out a list of the most reliable auto makers every year. They take data for actual owners so I would imagine their info would be the most accurate.

My father had a Lexus and a MB at the same time and by far the Lexus was much more reliable... but he still loved his E-class. As for me, I wasn't very impressed with the E-class. It was nice and all but I don't think it was worth the $50+K he paid for it back in 2003.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
I wasn't a fan of the older Lexus vehicles but the new lineup is attractive.

I find that reliability is a hit or miss. I've heard of owners who have continuous problems with their japanese cars.
I think Consumer Reports and JD Power (BTW, it is not Powers) put out a list of the most reliable auto makers every year. They take data for actual owners so I would imagine their info would be the most accurate.

My father had a Lexus and a MB at the same time and by far the Lexus was much more reliable... but he still loved his E-class. As for me, I wasn't very impressed with the E-class. It was nice and all but I don't think it was worth the $50+K he paid for it back in 2003.
I give Japanese car makers credit for building such reliable vehicles but what BMW and Mercedes vehicles have in them compared to their Japanese rivals, you realize that if you want a true premium vehicle, BMW or Benz is where it's at.

Lexus is stepping up but they have a while to go before they become anything like BMW or Benz.

What Lexus model did your father own?
I give Japanese car makers credit for building such reliable vehicles but what BMW and Mercedes vehicles have in them compared to their Japanese rivals, you realize that if you want a true premium vehicle, BMW or Benz is where it's at.

Lexus is stepping up but they have a while to go before they become anything like BMW or Benz.

What Lexus model did your father own?
He had an ES.
In this new era though I would like to give Mercedes and BMW before we really do a in depth convo about the reliability I think we should give them some time.
Japanese autos are going downward in reliability not because they are being build in the USA or Mexico. Quality control is the same. Most critical assembly is by robot. And, if you're like me and have taken apart a lot of cars being a car audio installer, it's really hard to goof up where a plug goes or how a plug goes into its mate... really hard. So to say an American can't do it but a German can? No. What the problem is is that your Toyotas, Fords, Mercedes-es, and Hyundais, etc., are sourcing parts from parts suppliers that are (1) the designer of said part and (2) produce them in China and other places where there is a legitimate quality control concern to be had.
All I can speak to is my own experience. My 2014 Cla 250 had an unusual number of problems. Prior, I had a Jetta diesel, that also had an unusual number of problems.
I owned the Jetta for 5 years, it had a blown turbo, complete exhaust sys replacement (probably a consequence of the blown turbo) , alternator, rear window motor,
all this, under warranty. The dealer almost talked me into a 4K out of pocket DPF storage cat replacement (fixed via Italian Tune-up: driving the at higer rpm-s for a while)
At which point it was time to part with the car: do I really want a $4k Damocles sword hanging over my head?

I swore never a German car again, but got seduced by the cla 250. "It is 2014 now, surely they worked out all the kinks, what could possibly go wrong?".
This car spends a fair amount of time at the dealer.
Failed water pump at 24K, various engine computer problems. Brake pulsing (front pads and rotor replaced 2x) . Left rear speaker blown ( Harman Kardon radio). Radar sensor replaced.
After water pump work, the car developed a rattle/rumble in the engine compartment. Dealer claims, this is now fixed. I say, nay! If the car needs any parts, it is a 1-2 week wait, to be shipped
from Germany.
So far, I have been covered under warranty, and usually they give me a nice loaner. The only thing that was somewhat painful is having to listen to my wife because
the car had to be towed when she was driving it. (the water pump affair...)

Looking at the repair costs (which they tend to put down on the work orders), all these repairs would have been very expensive, if I had to pay out of pocket. E.g.:
Water pump: parts and labor $800.
Dealer maintenace, "A" service: "The home of the $185 oil change" They say: it is a lot more than an oil change. I say, it _is_ an oil change, evidenced by the work order.
"B" service: Oil change, cabin air filter, brake fluid change. $385. (Truth be told, I prepaid $800 for 2x A and 2x B.)
Oh.. almost forgot rhe run-flat tires. I hate to think of the procedure should I pick up a nail. Probably involves bending over.
The user's manual says something about driving to the dealer, should that happen.

So: How costly is this car going to be, once you are out of warranty? ( Say, compared to some common sense car?).
Obviously you could just let the little things go. Parking sensors? Stereo? Noises? Just live with it.
Try to fix anything you can fix... But these cars are not easy to work on. Try to get a factory service manual?
Brakes, oil change, filters: doable. The parts cost 2-3x of an Asian/Domestic car.

Dont get me wrong: I love German cars. They drive like nothing else out there. But my 2c is : From my experience, they appear unreliable and expensive to repair.
See less See more
beginning to get nervous

Just picked up a 2014 CLA on Halloween of all days. Now reading Coder's post makes me nervous. What have I got my self into? This is my first Mercedes. So far the front discs appear to be warped and the Harmon-Kardon woofer isn't woofing. Looking forward to see what I get for a loaner.
I have had no issues with my CLA45 since I bought it almost a year ago other than an issue with the pause/mute button which required a reinstall of the system (which was free). I don't know how much more expensive this car will be as it gets older, but I went in fully expecting a more expensive maintenance bill.

With regards to the discs being warped, I think other people had issues with that. You may want to browse the forum. I don't think it ended up being a disc issue.

As to the HK system, I think it has more than enough bass. I don't usually go around with the bass thumping (I don't like my cars to shake and rattle) but it definitely goes high enough on my car for me to hate it. Personally I think quality audio systems in a car are overkill since there is so much background noise from the car/road/air and for the most part we play 128kbps mp3s from streaming sites. Even 320kbps only gets you so far. A really good audio system can't really shine unless you are using uncompressed music like from a CD (or at least lossless formats). I'm always amazed by people who will spend hundreds of dollars on expensive headphones only to listen to 128kbps audio from iTunes. Heck I had music in the late 90s when I was a schoolkid that were higher quality.
See less See more
1 - 18 of 18 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top